Looking for the best cookie sheet? America’s Test Kitchen has you covered. Our experts evaluated all the top-selling models to find the one that produces evenly baked cookies every time. Whether you’re a novice baker or serious cookie connoisseur, this guide will help you choose the perfect sheet for your needs. So what are you waiting for? Start baking!
Table of Contents
List of The Best Cookie Sheet America’s Test Kitchen In 2022
What is a cookie sheet?
A cookie sheet is a flat baking pan that is used to cook cookies. The surface of the pan is typically nonstick, which helps the cookies slide off easily. Cookie sheets come in different sizes, and some are even designed for special purposes like making pizzas or roasting vegetables.
What are cookie sheets used for?
Cookie sheets are most commonly used to make cookies, but they can also be used for other tasks like baking pastries or roasting vegetables. They work well because the surface is nonstick, which prevents the food from sticking to the pan and making a mess.
Reviews of The Best Cookie Sheet America’s test kitchen in 2022
Top 1 – Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet
Are you tired of scraping sticky cookies off your baking sheet every time? Why not consider the Nordic Ware Aluminum Baker’s sheet for a carefree cuisine experience. This product is an A-rated design crafted from the Nordic Ware brand. The company is a famous industry popular in the consumer market for pioneering natural aluminum bakeware for over 15 years.
This best Cookie Sheet America’s test kitchen is manufactured with pure aluminum material that will last a long time. Owing to this, the cooking sheet won’t wear or rust anytime soon. Similarly, the utensil features a classic silver coating that will complement your kitchen decor.
Also, the unit allows for even and golden baking results. Due to its supreme heat conductivity, you are sure to have your spiced crispy cookies ready in fewer minutes. Likewise, the hardened alloy helps provide uniform heat that maximizes scratch resistance.
Furthermore, this bakeware features a nonstick surface. The non-porous aluminum is stick-resistant and allows for easy scraping after use.
In addition, this baking sheet comes with standard dimensions for a perfect catering exercise. The cooking gear features exterior dimensions of about 17.88 x 12.88 x 1.06 inches. Coupled with interior dimensions of about 16.5 x11.38 x 1 inches, the Nordic pan can fit both modern and traditional ovens.
More so, the frying tool is versatile and compatible with varied baking mats. The pan will work well with parchment paper or silicone baking mats.
What’s best?
This unit is easy to use and clean. Before or after subsequent use, simply hand wash with soapy water. Dishwasher use is not advised as this may lead to discoloration.
Pros
- Nonstick surface
- Premium aluminum material
- Supreme heat conductivity
- Encapsulated rim that prevents warping
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Can warp at high temperatures
- Not dishwasher safe
Top 2 – USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet, Large, Warp Resistant Nonstick Baking Pan
Are you a chef? Or do you wish to advance your catering career? The USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet might be just what you need. This equipment is another high-quality collection from the USA pan brand. The company is a renowned industry in the utensil market famous for its durable bakewares and elegant craftsmanship.
This model is built with alloy steel material that can withstand diverse conditions. As a result, the pan can survive years without rusting. You can easily create kitchen success stories with the bakeware without stressing about purchasing a new one anytime soon.
Also, the cuisine sheet features a heavy gauge aluminized steel, and the steel helps enhance rapid heat distribution in fewer minutes. Carefully put the unit in the oven, and your seasoned chicken will be ready in minutes.
Furthermore, the equipment comes with a proprietary nonstick coating. The coating allows for the consistent release of food debris on the surface. It further features a non-toxic coating for a healthy cuisine routine.
Thanks to its fluted design, the rib-like texture helps reduce surface contact between the sheet and the dough. It as well helps increase air circulation for adequate heat distribution.
Unlike your traditional design, this model is manufactured to suit different heat boxes. The unit features inner dimensions of about 17×12.25 inches and outer dimensions of 18×13.9375×0.750 inches.
What’s better?
This culinary kit is easy to tidy. Carefully hand scrub and wash with hot water and mild soap. It is advisable not to use a metal sponge or sharp components on the pan.
Pros
- Durable alloy steel material
- Stick-free surface
- Easy to clean
- Even heat distribution
Cons
- It could be more versatile
Top 3 – OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half Sheet 13 x 18 Inch
Earning the third spot is the OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half Sheet 13 x 18 Inches. This product is an A-rated utensil designed for easy and efficient cooking exercise. The kit is a top-ranked model manufactured from the Oxo brand. The brand is another popular industry known for its elegant and outstanding collections in the global market.
This best Cookie Sheet America’s test kitchen is crafted from a durable stainless steel material that is a friend of time. Owing to this, the sheet will last long and won’t wear. Similarly, the dish is coated with a shiny, elegant finish. With this, the sheet will be a nice addition to your kitchen set.
Also, this gear is light weighted and storage-friendly. The product is equipped with a handle lock for safe storage, and it will also fit your cabinet top with zero stress. Likewise, its lightweight structure enables users to lift and transport around the kitchen environment easily.
Furthermore, the catering dish features spring-loaded handles. The handles enable users to leverage hence reducing hand strain. Effortlessly grab the non slip handles for a secure and comfortable grip.
Finally, the unit is easy to use and clean, and it’s ceramic reinforced coating allows for the easy and total removal of unwanted stains.
Pros
- Textured surface
- Easy to clean
- Storage-friendly
- Spring-loaded handles
Cons
- Not dishwasher safe
Top 4 – Good Cook Cookie Baking Sheet, 15 x 10 Inch, Gray
Enjoy a lifetime culinary experience with the Good Cook Cookie Baking Sheet. This kit is one of the best American test kitchen cookie sheets to make your cooking life more manageable.
Unlike your traditional trays, this pan is ideal for all fries. The dish comes with a nonstick coating for easy and perfect cleaning. With this, customers can quickly get rid of sticky food without breaking a sweat.
In addition, the tray features a professional gauge steel construction. The sturdy design helps protect the catering sheet from breaking, warping, or scratching.
Pros
- Sturdy gauge steel construction
- Easy to clean
- Nonstick surface
- Versatile
Cons
- Quality could be better
Top 5 – Nordic Ware Prism Half Sheet, Metallic
This review is not complete without the Nordic Ware Prism Half Sheet, Metallic. This bakeware is another outstanding collection from the Nordic company. The unit is built with a premium aluminum material that is 100% durable. As a result, the best Cookie Sheet America’s test kitchen won’t break or warp.
Thanks to its grid pattern, your flavored cake will come out tasty and appealing to the sight. The grid further helps improve airflow for an even and perfect brown-baked result.
Also, the cooking tray is easy to clean and use. Its patterned nonstick surface enables easy release of sticky components. Simply hand wash and keep away from sharp utensils.
Pros
- Perfect heat distribution
- Easy to use
- High-quality material
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Not dishwasher safe
What are some features to look for in the best cookie sheet America’s test kitchen?
When considering which cookie sheet to buy, there are a few things you should keep in mind.
First, think about the size of the pan. Cookie sheets come in many different sizes, so you should choose one that is best suited for your needs.
Second, consider whether you want a nonstick surface or not. Some people prefer nonstick surfaces because food doesn’t stick to them as easily, but others find them difficult to clean.
Finally, think about what kind of material you want your cookie sheet to be made out of. Cookie sheets can be made from aluminum, copper, silicone, or cast iron, among other materials. Each has its own benefits and drawbacks.
So there you have it! Now you know what a cookie sheet is and what to look for when buying one. Next time you’re in the market for a new baking pan, be sure to consider a cookie sheet. They’re great for all kinds of baked goods!
Types Material of Cookie Sheet America’s test kitchen
There are a few different materials that cookie sheets can be made out of, including aluminum, copper, silicone, and cast iron. Each material has its own benefits and drawbacks.
Aluminum
Aluminum is the most common material for cookie sheets. It’s lightweight and conducts heat well, so cookies cook evenly on it. However, aluminum can also be a little bit pricey.
Copper
Copper is another popular material for cookie sheets. It’s also lightweight and conducts heat well, but it’s also expensive. Additionally, copper can be a little bit harder to clean than other materials.
Silicone
Silicone is a newer material that is becoming increasingly popular for cookie sheets. It’s nonstick, meaning that food doesn’t stick to it easily, and it’s also heat resistant. However, silicone can be a bit more expensive than other materials.
Cast iron
Cast iron is a durable material that is often used for baking pans. It heats slowly but retains heat well, which results in even baking. However, cast iron can be quite heavy and difficult to maneuver. Additionally, it’s important to season cast iron cookware before using it, or food may stick to it.
So there you have it! Now you know about the different materials that cookie sheets can be made out of and the benefits and drawbacks of each one. Next time you’re in the market for a new baking pan, be sure to consider a cookie sheet. They’re great for all kinds of baked goods!
Q: How do I clean a cookie sheet?
A: Cookie sheets can be cleaned in a few different ways. Some people prefer to hand wash them, while others put them in the dishwasher. If you choose to hand wash your cookie sheet, be sure to use hot water and soap. If you put it in the dishwasher, be sure to select the appropriate cycle and avoid using harsh detergents, as they can damage the surface of the pan.
Q: How do I store a cookie sheet?
A: When not in use, you can store your cookie sheet in a variety of places. Some people choose to keep it in their kitchen cupboard, while others put it in a drawer or even outside in the garage. Just be sure to keep it in a place where it will not be damaged and is easily accessible when you need it.
Conclusion
The best cookie sheet America’s test kitchen is the one that will fit your needs. If you need a durable, heavy-duty cookie sheet, the Baker’s Secret is perfect. However, if you are looking for a nonstick baking sheet with a silicone grip, the Nordic Ware is the clear winner.
Whichever option you choose, make sure to read the reviews before purchasing to ensure that you are getting the best possible product for your money. Thanks for reading our blog post on America’s Test Kitchen’s top three picks for best cookie sheets!
Refer:
- https://www.thespruceeats.com/choose-baking-sheets-for-cookies-1907161
- https://www.foodandwine.com/cooking-techniques/baking/best-cookie-sheets
See also:
Leave a Reply