Cookie Scoop

The Best Cookie Scoop Cook’s Illustrated & America’s Test Kitchen for 2021

Those delicious, uniform and attractively displayed meatballs, cupcakes, cookies, ice creams, sorbets and other treats aren’t made by magic; the best cookie scoops were only used to achieve a perfect result.

Cookie Scoop
Cookie Scoop

For those unacquainted with cookie scoops, they are spring-loaded scoops that enable you to measure and scoop doughs and batters. Although they are called cookie scoops, they can also be used for portioning cupcakes, muffins and dough. Cookie scoops ensure a uniform dough size, thereby producing a final product that can compete with those made by professional chefs.

In this article, we will consider the best cookie scoop America’s Test Kitchen. So, if you are in search of the best product, then you are just in luck. Let’s begin already, shall we?

Reviews of America’s Test Kitchen Best Cookie Scoop

There are many products on the market, no doubt, but only the top six have been selected for detailed review. Here they are:

1. OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop: Best

Best Cookie Scoop
OXO Good Grips

OXO is one of the best kitchenware brands, and the OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop is no exception. Its handle is soft and comfortable and is spring-loaded; this absorbs pressure, giving it a simple squeeze.

Its wiper cleanly and easily ejects even the stickiest of dough; this feature ensures the cookies are uniform and that they will bake evenly. It has 20 portioners; this holds up to 3 tablespoons of dough while yielding 3 ½ -inch diameter cookies.

Also, the cookie scoop is dishwasher safe, making it easy to maintain. It has an aesthetic and ergonomic design and cushions high pressure, thereby protecting your hands during use. It is made of stainless-steel material, has a dimension of 2.7 x 1.5 x 10.2 inches and a weight of 3.2 ounces.


  • Warranty included
  • Ergonomic design
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Soft-padded grips


  • Fragile mechanism
  • Too large

2. Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set

Best Cookie Scoop

This product is an excellent gift to a loved one. The lustrous scoops come in a beautiful gift pack. But beyond its aesthetic look, it is a good quality product guaranteed to stand the test of time. It includes three scoops of various sizes, ideal for different scooping purposes, with all three being made with 18/8 stainless steel.

Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set has an ergonomic design; this enables the disher to glide easily without putting pressure on your hands and wrist. It is a heavy-duty product that’s made to last. It won’t rust or corrode and is mirror polished to give it a beautiful look all the time.

Besides, it is dishwasher safe and can be used for scooping ice cream, sorbet, gelato, cupcakes, muffins (12 cup pan), cookies, truffle, melon balls and so on.


  • Versatile use
  • Solid build
  • Aesthetic design
  • Rust and corrosion-resistant


  • Its durability needs to be improved on
  • Superfluous packaging makes it very expensive.

3. Norpro Grip-EZ 2-Teaspoon Stainless Scoop: best cookie scoop wirecutter

Best Cookie Scoop
Norpro Grip-EZ

Say no to messy cooking and yes to clean, easy and fast cooking experience with Norpro Grip-EZ 2-Teaspoon Stainless Scoop. The stainless-steel scoop has soft grip spring-loaded handles to cushion high pressure. The heavy-duty, spring action releases food using a sliding band beneath the scoop.

The all-purpose scoop is ideal for scooping frozen yogurt, ice cream, meatballs, cookie dough, vegetable purees and rice dishes. It is made of an ergonomic, elegant design and is lightweight. However, this product is the best hand washed. It weighs 5.6 ounces and has a dimension of 7.5 x 0.75 x 2.5 inches.


  • Sturdy scoop
  • Ergonomic and elegant
  • Resistant and durable
  • Ease of use


  • Falls apart quickly
  • Some models have sharp edges.

4. Zeroll Universe Standard Length EZ Disher Food Portion Control Scoop

Best Cookie Scoop
Zeroll Universe

From its ergonomic design, accurate portioning to its ease of use and elegant design, Zeroll Universe Standard Length EZ Disher Food Portion Control Scoop is one product made just for you. The product is designed to reduce pressure. Its new, lightweight design enables users to use it for a long time, while its plastic gear promotes a smooth operation.

Also, it is made of color-coded handles; this helps in easy size identification. It is designed to make scooping easy with its one-piece design. There are no springs to be replaced and can be used by either left- or right-hand users.

Its size is suitable for uniform cooking and serving. Its design ensures easy thumb activation and hand squeeze with fast, dependable delivery. It is also dishwasher safe.


  • Ergonomic design
  • Delivers accurate portions
  • Sturdy product
  • Color-coded for easy identification of sizes


  • Ideal for muffins but not cupcakes
  • Metal strip not properly flushed to the device

5. Vollrath 1-5/8 oz Stainless Steel Disher

Best Cookie Scoop

This 1-5/8 oz capacity Disher has a spring for easy use; it is made of stainless steel. Hence, it is resistant to rust and corrosion. It measures 8.75-inches in length with a diameter of 2-inches. Vollrath 1-5/8 oz Stainless Steel Disher has a full color-coded propylene handle for easy grip and ergonomic use.

Also, it features an inbuilt stopper notch, which prevents food from spilling, while the handle has a ribbed surface along with Aglon antimicrobial protection. The handle has a one-piece design; this prevents the crevices from collecting bacteria.

Furthermore, it is NSF certified, a mark of its quality and safety. The disher number is stamped, while the handle is color-coded for easy identification.


  • Sturdy and durable
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to use
  • Color-coded handle for ease of identification


  • Lever sticks out of the box
  • Gears don’t align with the holes

6. Kitchenaid Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop

Best Cookie Scoop

We round off our list with the Kitchenaid Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop, a product with an aesthetic look and modern design. Its spring handle cushions high pressure, while the body, which is made of stainless steel, is resistant to rust and scratch.

Besides, its ergonomic design gives it an ease of use. It is also dishwasher safe. The scoop is easy to use and gives a uniform scoop; this is due to its spring-loaded mechanism, which releases a measured dough scoop with just the handle’s squeeze. Its soft-grip handle makes it comfortable to use while also ensuring its durability.


  • Features one-year hassle-free replacement and a lifetime warranty
  • Durable stainless steel
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easy to use the handle


  • Not very durable
  • Leaves some dough in the scoop

Buying Guide

Scooping cookies, meatballs and doughs with your hands isn’t always easy as there are likely to be mistakes made when cutting the dough into portions. They are never always the same thickness or size; this gives it an unattractive and tacky look. To get the perfect cookie that will be the envy of all, you need the right tools.

While many results to cutting doughs with spoons, this isn’t ideal, but with the best cookie scoop AMERICA’S TEST KITCHEN, you are sure to get consistent, uniform, delicious and elegant cookies every time. Cookie scoops aren’t just limited to cookies as they can also be used to prepare meatballs, cupcakes, muffins and other treats.

If you are in search of the best product on the market but can’t seem to decide on one, not to worry, we’ve got you covered. In this buying guide, we will be sharing tips that will help you select the best product. They include:

Size of Scoop

This is an important factor to consider when buying a cookie scoop. The size of cookies and treats to prepare should determine the size of the scoop to purchase. For instance, mini scoops are ideal for preparing mini cupcakes, medium scoops are best for ice cream balls or cookies, while big cookie scoops are suitable for large cupcakes or cookies and for adding fruit balls to your salad.

There are also scoops sold in multi-packs; these are the best option to go for as they come in various scoop sizes and are cheaper.


Cookie scoops are of various models and are made of different materials too. While some are made of metal, some others are made of plastic. Hence, the choice of the material to go for will depend on your requirement.

For instance, if you are looking for a cost-effective option, plastic is your go-to, just ensure the plastic is a high-quality one. Plastic scoops are non-toxic and will not release toxic materials into your food.

However, if you are in search of a durable and sturdy product, then scoops made of metal are your best choice. Stainless-steel, in particular, are rust and corrosion-resistant. They are also resistant to high impact and temperature changes. Oftentimes, they are specially treated to prevent the growth of pathogens and germs.

Product Design

When purchasing cookie scoops, watch out for those that are easy to use and those withs ergonomic handles. The handles must have a soft-padded handle for easy grip and must also be spring-loaded as this cushion high impact and causes less stress on the hand.

A high-quality cookie scoop features a mechanism for easy release of dough portion and is ideal for use, while the rigid ones should be avoided as they are difficult to use and causes the dough to stick in the scoop.


Different cookie scoop has different prices depending on the quality of the product. There are those with a low price-tag and the expensive ones, so your final decision will depend on how much you are willing to pay.

Deluxe scoops are ideal as they are fancy and made of good quality albeit expensive. Those made of plastics are also good and more affordable. In all, never purchase the cheapest or most expensive cookie scoop; the best thing to do would be to settle for a good quality product of average price.

Cookie Scoop Size Chart



  1. What else can I use a cookie scoop for?

A. Cookie scoops can also be used for portioning cupcake batter, meatballs, ice cream, sorbet, sandwich fillings, muffins and doughs.

2. What is the best size cookie scoop?

A. A cookie scoop size of 2-inches in diameter is an ideal size.

3. What is the best material for a cookie scoop?

A. Stainless steel remains the best choice as they are easy to use, dishwasher safe and durable.


While cookies and other treats gotten from stores are delicious and eye catching, nothing beats homemade meals. However, the stress of preparing one coupled with how unappealing they look may be a turn-off.

Not anymore though, with the best cookie scoop, your cookies and treats will look, feel and taste like those made from a cooking show.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *